20 March 2017
HMRC have published their statistics on the ‘tax gap’. This is the difference between the amount of tax due nationally and the amount collected, and has steadily reduced from a level of 8.3% in 2005/06 to 6.5% in 2014/15. As HMRC also states that it collected £518 billion of revenue in 2014/15 we can calculate that the total amount lost to tax evasion and avoidance amounts to £36 billion.
It would be too easy to postulate that if the Government could collect all these funds they would have a massive impact on the national debt or the NHS or whatever we collectively might consider to be in the country’s best interests. The fact is that reducing this percentage further will become increasingly difficult; there will always be a tax gap. However the UK’s gap is now one of world’s smallest. Even in the USA it is 16.3%, whereas in economies that are perceived to be less well-organised the figure is much higher, for example, Mexico: 23% and Italy: 34%.
HMRC’s efforts to reduce the tax gap fall broadly into two categories:
- more efficient reporting and collecting; and
- compliance and enforcement procedures.
HMRC claims these tax gap figures highlight the positive impact of digital reporting which makes it easier for people to pay the right amount of tax. This includes Real Time Information for the PAYE system and the shift to VAT online. The latter, for example helped bring the VAT gap in 2014/15 to its lowest level of 10.3% (£12.7 billion).
Since 2010 HMRC have invested £1.8 billion in compliance and a spokesman said that it would continue to reduce the tax gap “by relentlessly pursuing the small minority who seek to cheat their taxes through evasion, aggressive avoidance and organised crime.”
This included taking action to clamp down on the organised crime gangs behind the illicit trade in tobacco and alcohol.
It also includes new legislation aimed at deterring people from using “tax avoidance arrangements”.
The Serial Tax Avoiders Regime (STAR)
There is currently no legislative regime dealing specifically with serial tax avoiders but this new measure will come into full effect from 6 April 2017 and will mainly impact on taxpayers who repeatedly use tax avoidance schemes.
HMRC describes these schemes as those which “look to exploit tax reliefs in a way not intended by Parliament or to unfairly inflate the relief gained”. If such an arrangement is finally defeated (ie. the position can no longer be argued or amended), HMRC can issue STAR warning notices, which are aimed at changing the behaviour of the taxpayer concerned. The notice will cover a five year period. During this time, taxpayers will be required to notify HMRC each year that they have not used any further avoidance schemes, or if they have, to give full details of the schemes and the amount of the tax advantage the schemes are asserted to deliver.
For taxpayers who use further avoidance schemes while under warning which HMRC defeat, they will become liable to a penalty of 20% of the understated tax. Subsequent defeats of such schemes will result in increasing penalties to a maximum of 60%.
Taxpayers who use three schemes during a warning period which HMRC defeats will have their names and other details published by HMRC.
Interestingly this measure appears to be primarily one of justice and fairness since its economic impact on the Exchequer is predicted to be negligible.
There is no right of appeal against a STAR warning notice so it is important that taxpayers understand the steps they could choose to take to potentially protect themselves from becoming part of the regime.
We at UHY are very keen to help you to minimise your tax liabilities by claiming all the reliefs that Parliament intended you to have and by organising your affairs legitimately in order to minimise the effects of taxation. After all, to quote Morgan Stanley: "You must pay taxes. But there's no law that says you gotta leave a tip." However, we never condone aggressive or artificial schemes of the sort that are invented and promoted by some specialist tax lawyers. These are now a prime target for HMRC and many will be defeated leading to substantial fines and legal costs.
If you have subscribed to a scheme whose commercial purpose is dubious and whose main objective is tax avoidance you should consider making full disclosure before 6 April. You should also urgently contact me or your local UHY tax partner. For further information on the disclosure of tax avoidance scheme, visit this Governmental website.