VAT accounting for charities is seldom straightforward and can bring many risks when incorrectly applied.  VAT errors can bring financial exposure, reputational damage and unwelcome scrutiny, which can be significant.

Why VAT deserves trustee attention

Trustees have ultimate responsibility for tax compliance and governance. Beyond the financial risk, VAT errors can lead to time‑consuming engagement with HM Revenue and Customs and reputational concerns. Just as importantly, weak VAT governance can mean charities fail to recover VAT they are legitimately entitled to, putting unnecessary pressure on already stretched resources.

Common VAT risk hotspots /pitfalls

There are many VAT pitfalls that can arise for charities. For example, where activities of a charity evolve significantly, but the charity’s VAT recovery method has remained unchanged, this can lead to under/over‑recovery of VAT or positions difficult to justify, resulting in unwelcome financial impact.

Incorrect income classification is another common issue. For example, incorrectly distinguishing between grant income and business income. Getting this wrong can significantly impact VAT recovery and compliance.

VAT compliance issues represent a clear and significant risk to the charity and its trustees. The difference between VAT as a source of risk and VAT as a source of resilience is highly influenced by the governance framework and leadership culture in place within charity organisations.

VAT governance in practice

Appropriate VAT governance does not mean turning trustees into VAT specialists. It does mean ensuring VAT is considered at the right level and at the proper time so there is clarity over how risk is identified, reviewed and managed.

Trustees and finance committees should understand where VAT is most material to their organisation and when advice should be sought, particularly during periods of change. Documenting VAT positions and the rationale behind them is key as this can make a significant difference if questions arise later.

Practical steps to move from risk to resilience

Resilience comes from a small number of consistent behaviours. In our experience, charities that manage VAT well tend to do a few things consistently:

  • proactively build regular VAT reviews/health checks into management processes and consider VAT implications before changes occur (rather than waiting for problems to arise at a later stage)
  • regularly review and update their VAT recovery methodology as activities evolve and operate robust apportionment methods
  • review and monitor the VAT treatment of income streams and identify all available VAT reliefs to maximise savings
  • avoid reliance on a single individual by having strong internal VAT processes, controls, proper documentation and by sharing VAT knowledge within the wider finance and commercial teams
  • encourage a culture where historic VAT positions can be discussed and challenged constructively if errors are identified
  • keep up to date with changes in VAT law/guidance and seek VAT advice where required (such as for complex or unusual situations)

By recognising VAT as a strategic risk area and embedding it into leadership and finance processes, charities can move from managing risk reactively to navigating change with confidence, ensuring good governance. When embedded, these key VAT compliance checks allow charities to anticipate VAT risk in a managed way rather than reactively.

Added value

This approach not only results in structured tax governance, but it can also produce savings.  Some examples include:

  • our review of a recovery method resulted in a £600k refund for a charity
  • we secured the application of VAT reliefs, saving a charity £500k in respect of IT procurement
  • we introduced a development company that saved a charity £9m of VAT incurred on construction costs
  • we reviewed VAT mitigation options for a museum and identified £3.5m of VAT efficiencies

Note

This article is based on a comprehensive technical guide originally published by UHY for the Charity Finance Group (CFG). You can find the full, unabridged analysis in the CFG member resources here.

The next step

UHY’s specialist VAT team is led by partner Sean Glancy and director Lisa Burnside, who have extensive experience advising charities and not‑for‑profit organisations on VAT, governance and risk management. They work closely with trustees and finance teams to help organisations strengthen compliance frameworks and build financial resilience in an increasingly complex environment. For any VAT related enquiries, please get in touch.

Let's talk! Send an enquiry to your local UHY expert.

Get in touch