20 October 2012
Publications that covered this story include Financial Times Weekend and Independent, 22.10.2012.
- HMRC targeting small businesses with ‘low cost, high return’ strategy
- Crackdown hitting innovative growth businesses
The extra tax yield from compliance investigations into small and medium sized businesses by HM Revenue & Customs jumped 39% in the last year according to our research.
Investigations into SMEs* netted HMRC £434 million in extra tax and fines in 2011-12, a sharp increase from £311 million in 2010-11 (year end March 31). These figures are on top of taxes already paid by these businesses.
Roy Maugham, Tax Partner at our London office, says: “HMRC has been set a challenging tax yield target by the Chancellor, and small businesses have found that they are an easy target for HMRC’s crackdown.”
“Small businesses are more likely to make innocent errors in their tax calculations than larger businesses, meaning the small business community offers plenty of opportunity for HMRC.”
“Many businesses are still struggling during the recession so having to pay extra taxes, fines and interest is the last thing they need.”
Roy adds: “The other hidden cost to businesses is the amount of time it takes to deal with a tax investigation. An SME is also going to find it hard to afford a full time accountant to deal with or challenge a tax investigation so is more likely to concede, unnecessarily, to demands for extra tax.”
“Add this to HMRC’s tactic of sending multiple demands for additional payment for different taxes simultaneously to the same business, and small businesses can very quickly find themselves overwhelmed by the compliance burden.”
HMRC has been targeting tax areas that have previously been relatively overlooked, in an attempt to increase tax revenue.
Roy explains: “Areas like PAYE and VAT have always been scrutinised to an extent, but HMRC is now looking more closely at issues like corporate entertainment and employee benefits – such as company cars, private healthcare, or company-subsidised fuel costs – which had previously escaped serious scrutiny.”
“HMRC’s take on employee benefits in increasingly draconian, for example. They’re looking for any minor compliance slip by a business: whether it has reported the right thing at the right time, or challenging whether company cars are genuinely being used for company business at any given time.”
“Small businesses need to be aware of this when completing their tax returns. The days of HMRC having a relaxed approach to assessing deductions are long gone.”
HMRC is also challenging the tax returns of new types of businesses, as it seeks to find as much revenue as possible.
*Through business self-assessment

We produce a range of informative publications focusing on the latest accounting issues. Click to add yourself to our mailing list.
The amount of money put into ISAs has fallen for the first time ever. The total amount of new subscriptions into ISAs in 2011-12 dropped to £53.5billion, down from £53.
The number of businesses that have requested a National Insurance Contribution holiday plummeted to a new low of 400 in December 2012, down 44% from the 710 applications made in the same month the year before. This is the lowest take up of the scheme since January 2011 – just after the scheme launched – and less than a fifth of the 2,235 applications received at the scheme’s peak in October 2011.
The value of mergers and acquisitions targeting private companies has increased 50% in one year, up by £6.1 billion to £18.2 billion.
Businesses are losing out as HMRC’s internal VAT decision review process appears to be making decisions increasingly in HMRC’s favour,
George Osborne presented his Budget on Wednesday 20 March 2013 and there were few surprises. Amongst the detail there were some announcements which affect the charity and not-for-profit sector, and these have generally been warmly received by sector leaders.
Dundee and Aberdeen saw the UK’s biggest booms in household disposable income – the money a household has left to spend or save after taxes and mortgages or rent – over the last five years, according to our latest research.